John Romero Stresses Design as Most New Games Are Trash
John Romero, co-founder of id Software and co-creator of Wolfenstein 3D, Doom, and Quake, has warned that democratised development tools have flooded modern PC, console, and mobile storefronts with low-quality software. Speaking in an interview with FRVR reported by VGC, Romero noted that while publishing barriers have largely vanished outside Apple's USD $100 (~RM450 estimated) iOS developer licence fee, Android in particular suffers from a heavy monthly influx of AI-generated and kit-built titles. For Malaysian and Southeast Asian players and indie developers across Steam, console digital stores, mobile, Switch 2, PS5 Pro, Steam Deck, and ROG Ally ecosystems, storefront saturation reinforces why standout game design and curated physical distribution remain decisive differentiators.
Key Facts
John Romero's industry commentary highlights how accessible engines, SDKs, and digital storefronts have eliminated traditional publishing barriers while flooding PC, console, and mobile markets with low-quality software. Romero identifies only the USD $100 (~RM450 estimated) Apple iOS developer licence as a baseline monetary gatekeeper on Apple's mobile ecosystem.
| Attribute | Value |
| Key Industry Figure / Studio | John Romero (id Software co-founder; Wolfenstein 3D, Doom, Quake co-creator) |
| Platforms Referenced | PC (Steam, historical mail-order/shareware), Console digital stores, Android, Apple iOS |
| Source Publication Date / Verification | Verified 20 November 2026 (via FRVR interview reported by VGC) |
| Price / Publishing Fee Benchmark | USD $100 (~RM450 estimated conversion) for Apple iOS developer licence; JPY pricing not applicable |
| Physical Edition Context | Historical retail boxed PC distribution contrasted against modern self-published digital storefronts |
| Language Support Context | Not applicable to industry commentary; regional Asian/Japanese physical imports require per-title English SKU checks |
| Region & Hardware Compatibility | Global digital storefronts (Steam Deck, ROG Ally, Switch 2, PS5 Pro, Android, iOS ecosystems) |
Why Does Storefront Saturation Make Game Design Critical?
Storefront saturation makes game design critical because automated game-making kits and generative AI tools flood Steam, console digital stores, and Android with low-quality software every month. Without genuinely compelling design, self-published titles disappear rapidly from social feeds and digital catalogues before organic word-of-mouth recommendation can build momentum.
Romero emphasised that while console digital stores and Steam experience substantial shovelware volume, Android faces an even larger monthly wave of automated uploads. In the FRVR interview, Romero directly criticised the quality of much of this output while still defending open creative access.
"Most of them are trash. Most of them are AI-generated, or there's a game-making kit used to just generate them automatically, you know? A lot of them. But it's great, that the democratisation of getting your stuff out there is a reality now. Any little kid can get their game out there, just making something and go ahead and put it up there. It's awesome. I love that you can do that. There's not a barrier to doing that other than the hundred bucks that you have to pay to Apple for iOS developer license."
John Romero, co-founder of id Software, speaking to FRVR via VGC
Romero maintains that strong game design is the sole sustainable differentiator when automated tools eliminate technical publishing barriers.
How Do Modern Digital Barriers Compare With Early PC Distribution?
Modern digital distribution requires minimal upfront capital compared with the earlier days of PC gaming, when securing a retail publisher was difficult due to limited industry funding. Today, independent creators can utilise accessible engines, frameworks, and SDKs, facing primarily Apple's USD $100 (~RM450 estimated) iOS developer licence fee to publish software.
Reflecting on the launch era of Doom, Romero explained that distribution relied partly on mail-order and shareware, while traditional retail store placement felt like entering a completely separate commercial tier because the industry was far smaller. By contrast, modern indie teams face a visibility bottleneck rather than a manufacturing one, as posting a project to an audience of 57 followers on social media rarely gains traction.
"The ability is there now. You have engines, you have frameworks, you have so many SDKs and ways of building games. That's great. It can make everyone creative in another way, a new way, right? But it needs to be really good before anyone's going to care."
John Romero, co-founder of id Software, speaking to FRVR via VGC
To overcome digital obscurity, Romero advised independent creators to network actively and submit builds to indie game festivals so players can experience the work firsthand. Word-of-mouth advocacy triggered by high-quality design outperforms isolated social media promotion on crowded modern storefronts.
Southeast Asia & Malaysian Collector Verdict
For Malaysian and Southeast Asian players, storefront saturation on Steam, eShop, PlayStation Store, and mobile marketplaces makes curated discovery essential across Switch 2, PS5 Pro, Steam Deck, and ROG Ally. Physical Asian and Japanese import releases remain a practical quality filter for collectors prioritising verified preservation over uncurated digital listings.
- Physical vs. Digital Viability: On PC handhelds such as Steam Deck and ROG Ally, Steam's vast digital catalogue offers competitive regional Malaysian Ringgit pricing alongside heavy clutter, whereas Switch 2 and PS5 Pro players can lean on curated physical releases to avoid disposable digital shovelware.
- Import Language Verification: Collectors importing Asian or Japanese physical cartridges and discs via regional retailers or Play-Asia should confirm whether English voice and subtitle tracks are included on-cart or on-disc before ordering, as some Japanese SKUs omit English localisation despite shared hardware region compatibility.
- Landed Cost vs. Digital Convenience: Importing physical editions entails shipping and potential currency fluctuations compared with local Malaysian eShop or PSN digital releases, making physical investment most compelling for vetted indie standouts and long-term preservation rather than untested digital-only titles.
Malaysian collectors using physical Asian and Japanese imports benefit from commercial retail vetting that naturally filters out automated digital shovelware.
Common Questions
Malaysian developers and gamers navigating crowded storefronts frequently ask how indie releases gain visibility, which platforms face the worst shovelware, and whether physical imports offer better curation. Romero concludes that strong game design and direct community showcase events remain the most reliable path to organic player attention.
Which digital storefront did John Romero identify as having the worst low-quality influx?
Romero singled out Android as experiencing an even heavier monthly dump of low-quality releases than Steam or console digital stores. He attributed this volume largely to automated game-making kits and generative AI tools that allow unvetted titles to be uploaded with minimal oversight.
How does John Romero advise small indie teams with tiny followings to get noticed?
Rather than relying solely on social media posts with an example audience of 57 followers, Romero advises creators to network aggressively and enter indie game festivals. Placing a well-designed game directly in front of players drives the word-of-mouth discussion needed for organic growth.
Why do physical Asian imports still appeal to Malaysian console collectors amid digital saturation?
Physical Asian and Japanese editions sold through local retailers or Play-Asia undergo commercial manufacturing and distribution vetting, filtering out automated shovelware. Collectors on Switch 2 and PS5 Pro should verify English voice and subtitle support on-cart or on-disc before importing against local eShop or PSN pricing.
Sources and Methodology
This dispatch synthesises primary commentary by id Software co-founder John Romero originally given to FRVR and reported by VGC deputy editor Chris Scullion, verified on 20 November 2026. Estimated Malaysian Ringgit equivalents convert cited US dollar fees at an approximate market rate of USD $1 to RM4.50.
- Primary Industry Source: Video Games Chronicle (VGC), citing FRVR's interview with John Romero (https://www.videogameschronicle.com/news/now-more-than-ever-its-about-design-john-romero-loves-that-games-are-easier-to-make-but-warns-most-are-trash/).
- Pricing & Verification Methodology: Only figures explicitly stated in the source text (the USD $100 Apple iOS developer licence fee and the 57-follower social media example) are reported; Malaysian Ringgit figures are explicitly marked as approximate import/currency conversions.
Network · latest from the sister sites
From the network
Track Malaysian Import Prices Live
Importing Japanese or Asian physical games to Malaysia? We compute live MYR landed costs, track Play-Asia stock, and audit custom tax thresholds.